Domestic and family violence perpetrator screening and risk assessment in Queensland: Current practice and future opportunities
Silke Meyer, Nicola Helps and Kate Fitz-Gibbon
Abstract
Following substantial domestic and family violence (DFV) reforms in Australia in recent years, the identification of victim-survivors is increasingly embedded across service system responses. In contrast, while men using DFV often have diverse service system contact for co-occurring issues, their use of DFV is often not identified.
This mixed-methods study examines current screening and risk assessment practices for DFV perpetration in service systems that frequently encounter men who may be using DFV, including mental health, alcohol and other drug services, corrections and child protection services. Results show significant variation in screening and risk assessment practices and attitudes across service areas.
Introduction
Domestic and family violence (DFV) affects one in four women in Australia and is the leading preventable contributing factor to women’s illness, disability and death (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare 2019). While not solely perpetrated by men against women, DFV remains highly gendered, with women and children over-represented as victims (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare 2019; World Health Organization 2021). This is especially the case at the high-risk end, with an average of one woman being killed by a male intimate partner every nine days in Australia (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare 2021).
The last eight years have seen unprecedented attention at the national and state levels focused on improving and reforming responses to DFV. Recent reviews including Victoria’s Royal Commission into Family Violence (2016), the Special Taskforce on Domestic and Family Violence in Queensland’s (2015) Not now, not ever report and the Council of Australian Governments (2011) Advisory Panel on Reducing Violence against Women and their Children have revealed the need to develop new policies and practices to better respond to perpetrators of family violence. While significant attention has been paid to ensuring risk identification, assessment and management practices are in place for DFV victim-survivors, understanding of and responses to perpetrators of DFV remain limited and inconsistent. In particular, identifying DFV perpetrators and assessing and managing risk falls largely on police, courts and DFV specialist services, such as men’s behaviour change programs (McEwan, Shea & Ogloff 2019; Storey et al. 2014). Screening and risk assessment for DFV used in other service areas remain primarily victim-centred (Messing & Thaller 2013; Penti, Timmons & Adams 2018; Todahl & Walters 2011), often rendering perpetrators invisible to the service system.
Research on men who use DFV highlights the complex intersecting issues these men often present with, including mental health problems, alcohol and other drug (AOD) misuse, risk associated with their role as a parent or other offending behaviour (Domestic and Family Violence Death Review and Advisory Board (DFVDRAB) 2021; Hester et al. 2015; Spangaro et al. 2017; Verbruggen et al. 2020). There is substantial co-occurrence between men’s primary presenting issues in these service areas and their use of DFV (Gilchrist et al. 2019; Kraanen et al. 2013; Verbruggen et al. 2020). Health services, corrections and child protection services therefore present key opportunities to identify male perpetration of DFV and to assess and manage related risk. However, current international research evidence suggests that identification of and responses to perpetrators in these settings remains limited (Davis & Padilla-Medina 2021), with Australian evidence being scant (Tarzia et al. 2017).
Conclusion
The absence of standard screening questions and actuarial risk assessment tools to elicit indicators of DFV perpetration and related risk across Queensland services is problematic. To equip frontline practitioners across non-DFV specialist service areas to conduct screening for perpetration through a combination of direct screening questions and professional judgement, practitioners require consistent access to DFV specialist training and regular professional development. This should include developing knowledge in established and emerging forms of abuse, available referral pathways and support mechanisms, as well as relevant legislative changes. Potential DFV perpetration will likely remain invisible to many frontline practitioners unless practitioners are equipped with knowledge and awareness of perpetrator patterns of denial, minimisation, manipulation and system abuse. Further, practitioners require knowledge of adequate referral pathways for men using DFV to confidently identify potential DFV perpetration.
Implementing consistent screening protocols, including combining direct screening questions with DFV-informed professional judgement, is recommended across practice areas. This will require organisational leadership and a whole-of-system commitment. Our findings show that the application of a DFV-informed lens, to client interactions broadly and to male clients who may be perpetrating DFV specifically, is more pronounced in organisations and service areas with strong commitment to DFV reforms and leadership around DFV-informed practice. Organisational leadership in DFV[1]informed practice is a key aspect of ensuring that identifying and responding to male clients using DFV becomes core business across all non-DFV specialist practice areas. The change required must go beyond the practice areas captured in the current study and extend to other areas frequently responding to victim-survivors and perpetrators of DFV, including disability services, Centrelink, housing services, non-statutory child and family welfare services, family law services, legal services and First Nations and culturally and linguistically diverse support services.
2023. Domestic and family violence perpetrator screening and risk assessment in Queensland: Current practice and future opportunities. Trends & issues in crime and criminal justice no. 660. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology. https://doi.org/10.52922/ti78818
Need legal advice?
If you've been charged or contacted by police, get advice early. Mark Savic is available 24/7 for urgent matters in Airlie Beach, the Whitsundays and across Queensland.



