How much does prison really cost? Comparing the costs of imprisonment with community corrections – Part 1
Anthony Morgan
Executive summary
The costs associated with managing offenders in prison and in the community can be significant. Estimated costs are usually derived from the Report on government services, which reports both the operating expenditure and capital costs for prisons and community corrections. However, research has shown that sentencing a person to a period of incarceration can have much wider implications for the individual, their family, government and the broader community. These implications may be positive or negative, and may therefore generate both costs and savings.
Understanding the wider costs associated with different sentence options can be helpful in informing effective correctional policy and practice. Yet relatively few studies have attempted to estimate the wider costs or savings associated with pathways through imprisonment or community corrections.
The purpose of this research was to calculate the total net cost of pathways through imprisonment and community corrections in Victoria, taking into account a range of direct and indirect costs and savings associated with a matched cohort of prisoners and offenders. This study was undertaken in two stages. The first stage estimated the costs and savings accrued during sentences that began in 2009–10 (the reference episode). The second stage estimated the wider costs and savings for both this reference episode and subsequent pathways through imprisonment and community corrections over a five year period. The methodology used to develop these estimates and the results are presented in this report.
Introduction
The costs associated with managing offenders in prison and in the community can be significant. Estimated costs are usually derived from the Steering Committee for the Review of Government Service Provision’s Report on government services, which reports both the operating expenditure and capital costs for prisons and community corrections (SCRGSP 2016). According to this report, in 2014–15 the total net operating expenditure and capital costs for imprisonment in Victoria were $837 million, while the total for community corrections was $109 million (Figure 1). This is equivalent to $361 per prisoner per day and $28 per offender per day, respectively.
These figures are often cited in discussions about the cost of imprisonment (Gelb 2011; Victorian Ombudsman 2015). Comparisons between the cost of imprisonment and the cost of community corrections are often made by extrapolating the daily cost for prisoners and offenders to annual estimates or estimates for the average prison sentence (Gelb 2011; Smart Justice 2011). However, comparing annual estimates overlooks the fact that the length of sentence may vary significantly depending on whether an offender receives a custodial or non-custodial sentence. Similarly, estimates that rely on average sentence lengths do not account for the fact that offenders may have their actual sentence length amended due to good or bad behaviour, may receive multiple consecutive sentences, or may move between different types of orders (eg when they are released on parole or resentenced to imprisonment as a result of breaching a community order).
Further, research has shown that sentencing a person to a period of incarceration can have much wider implications for the individual, their family, government and the broader community (deVuono-powell et al. 2015; Gelb 2011; Travis, Western & Redburn 2014). These implications may be positive or negative, and can therefore generate both costs and savings. There is evidence that prison can have an incapacitation effect when prisoners are incarcerated (Weatherburn, Hua & Moffatt 2006), and this reduction in offending means a reduction in the associated costs of crime (Smith et al. 2014). Conversely, research has also suggested that imprisonment may have a criminogenic effect (Travis, Western & Redburn 2014), meaning higher crime costs associated with increased recidivism after a prisoner leaves prison. While there is research that shows that participation in correctional employment and education programs can increase employment for prisoners post-release (compared with those prisoners who do not participate; Davis et al. 2013), research has also shown that, overall, prison may have a negative impact on prisoners’ future earnings, if not their actual employment prospects (Holzer 2007; Kleykamp, Rosenfeld & Scotti 2008; Knuutila 2010; Travis, Western & Redburn 2014; Velamuri & Stillman 2007). The impact of imprisonment on housing stability and therefore homelessness can increase the need for housing support services (Baldry et al. 2006), while the impact on families can also have important cost implications, some tangible and others less tangible (deVuono-powell et al. 2015). Upon entering prison, prisoners have been shown to have poorer physical and mental health than the population in general and, while there may be increased access to diagnosis and treatment for existing health conditions, there is some (limited) evidence of health improving during incarceration in some ways and deteriorating in others (Travis, Western & Redburn 2014).
Understanding the true costs associated with different sentence options can help inform effective correctional policy and practice (Travis, Western & Redburn 2014). Changes to sentencing policy can have a significant impact on the number of individuals in prison or under community supervision, which in turn affects the cost of corrections. In Victoria, the rates of imprisonment and community corrections have both gradually increased over the past 10 years (Figure 2). But in recent years there have been significant changes to parole, the abolition of suspended sentences, the introduction of new community orders and changes to the management of offenders in the community, all of which have had important implications for both the number of people in prison or under supervision and the direct cost of providing these services (Department of Justice and Regulation 2015; Tubex et al. 2015). As shown in Figure 1, in the last five years the total net operating expenditure and capital costs for prison and community corrections have increased by 37 percent and 45 percent, respectively.
Further, there is a historical relationship between the imprisonment rate and total recurrent criminal justice expenditure in Victoria, a pattern that has also been observed overseas (WSIPP 2003). As the imprisonment rate has increased, so too has the overall expenditure on police, courts and corrections (Figure 3).
But still there remains little evidence as to the real economic cost to government and the wider community of managing offenders in prison or in the community, beyond the immediate cost to government. Relatively few studies have attempted to estimate the wider costs or savings associated with imprisonment or community corrections, beyond the direct costs of offender management borne by non-correctional agencies (Henrichson, Rinaldi & Delaney 2015), cost-benefit analyses for alternatives to imprisonment (Deloitte Access Economics 2013; Lengyel & Brown 2009; Marsh & Fox 2008) or in terms of pathways through the criminal justice system (Baldry et al. 2012). For example, Marsh and Fox (2008) compared the economic efficiency of alternative sentencing options, finding that as well as costing less, enhancements to standard prison sentences and certain community-based interventions were more effective in reducing reoffending than prison, producing considerable savings. Their estimates, however, were based on the savings arising from crimes avoided, and relied on short-term effect sizes to derive lifetime estimates of reoffending.
Obtained from: How much does prison really cost? (aic.gov.au)
Need legal advice?
If you've been charged or contacted by police, get advice early. Mark Savic is available 24/7 for urgent matters in Airlie Beach, the Whitsundays and across Queensland.



