24/7 Hotline 0418 956 910 Free 30-minute consultation. Call to book Coral Sea Marina, Airlie Beach
Guardian Criminal Law

Police use of CCTV on the rail network

Police use of CCTV on the rail network

Police use of CCTV on the rail network

Anthony Morgan and Maggie Coughlan

Abstract

Despite support from police for the use of CCTV, and its popularity in public places, there has been limited research into the use of CCTV by police for investigative purposes.

The current study attempted to better understand police demand for CCTV footage from the NSW rail network. Results showed the police made an average of 17 requests per day for footage, mostly for criminal investigations. On both the metropolitan and intercity network, requests were more common for stations that recorded a higher number of incidents, had more cameras, and had fewer patrons. Once station characteristics were taken into account, the findings suggested that CCTV footage was more likely to be requested from those stations with lower levels of public surveillance.

This research can help to inform the design, layout and management of CCTV systems on public transport and in other locations.

Introduction

There is good reason to believe that police value closed-circuit television (CCTV) as an investigative tool. A small body of international research has shown that police frequently use CCTV as part of criminal investigations, for both minor and more serious offences (Ashby 2017; La Vigne et al. 2011; Levesley & Martin 2005; Piza, Caplan & Kennedy 2014). Several Australian police agencies have published online their general policies on the use of CCTV, which show they are supportive of the CCTV schemes operated by other organisations and the benefits they offer to law enforcement (eg NSW Police Force 2010; Victoria Police 2011). Other police agencies, along with the Australia New Zealand Policing Advisory Agency (ANZPAA) and National Policing Improvement Agency (NPIA) in the UK, have produced information guides for system operators to increase the likelihood that camera footage can be used by police (ANZPAA 2014; NPIA 2011; SA Police nd; Tasmania Police nd). More recently, police agencies have embraced new forms of video surveillance, including body-worn cameras (Cubitt et al. 2017).

Yet, despite this apparent interest in and use of surveillance footage, and frequent debate regarding the crime prevention benefits of CCTV, there has been limited Australian or international research on the use of CCTV footage by police as part of criminal investigations. Given the significant growth in CCTV (see Hulme, Morgan & Brown 2015), the substantial financial investment in CCTV by Commonwealth, state, territory and local governments and the private sector, and the commentary that exists around the merits of CCTV (eg Carr 2016, 2014; Taylor 2010; Taylor & Gill 2014), it is vital that this aspect of CCTV performance be better understood, particularly as it may help inform the design, layout, technical capabilities and monitoring and sharing arrangements for new and existing camera networks.

This paper explores the use of CCTV camera footage by police, with a specific focus on the use of footage from a major Australian rail network.

Discussion

It is possible to draw several conclusions from the results presented in this paper. First, while it is not possible to determine from this study how the footage was used or its impact, it is evident that rail network CCTV footage is frequently requested by police, with an average of 17 footage requests per day, and 14 requests per day for criminal investigations. At the very least, this volume of requests suggests that police in New South Wales see enough value in CCTV footage as a source of information for criminal investigations into incidents on the rail network to regularly request it from Sydney Trains. It also reflects the strong partnership that has been established between Sydney Trains and NSWPF (Sydney Trains 2016).

This high demand highlights the importance of careful planning of CCTV systems and management of footage by camera operators, particularly when cameras are installed in relatively high crime areas. Camera operators must be adequately resourced to meet this demand; otherwise their capacity to support investigators can be negatively affected (Piza, Caplan & Kennedy 2014). There are clear protocols that must be followed to enable camera footage to be used for evidentiary purposes, including legislative requirements, technical specifications, storage provisions and the access to and handling of footage in ways that ensure the integrity and continuity of evidence (ANZPAA 2014; NPIA 2011).

Regression analysis identified a number of station-level characteristics associated with a higher number of police requests for footage relating to assault incidents. As expected, the actual number of recorded incidents is an important predictor of the number of requests for footage, and remained significant once other station variables were taken into account. This highlights the importance of ensuring that, where they are designed to assist police, cameras are installed in higher crime areas (not limited to public transport), informed by data on the number of recorded incidents in those areas.

There are a number of possible explanations for why metropolitan stations recorded a higher number of footage requests than intercity stations, even controlling for the number of security incidents. There may be variation in the propensity of different police command areas to request footage. Variation between Police Transport Command areas in the number of requests for footage can be largely explained by local arrangements for access to footage (ie some intercity stations have local monitoring which enables police to review footage prior to submitting a request). In addition, those officers working at metropolitan stations, where incidents are more common, are more likely to have previous experience investigating crime at train stations and therefore greater awareness of the availability of CCTV footage. Officers responsible for investigating crime at metropolitan stations may have greater capacity to request and analyse footage or, conversely, seek camera footage because it may save valuable investigation time. Finally, it is possible that there are qualitative differences in the types of assault that occur at different stations, assaults at metropolitan stations may be more serious or more likely to involve multiple parties.

The number of cameras was a significant predictor of the number of requests for footage across metropolitan and intercity stations, controlling for both passenger footfall and the number of recorded incidents. This is consistent with the hypothesis that the more cameras there are (relative to patronage), the more likely it is that an incident will be captured and, in turn, the more likely it is that police will request footage. However, once the analysis was limited to metropolitan stations, the number of cameras was not a significant predictor of footage requests, either before or after the physical characteristics of train stations were taken into account. This may reflect the high degree of CCTV coverage that metropolitan stations have on the Sydney rail network, there may be little actual variation in the proportion of station area that has surveillance. Further research should explore the influence of camera dosage, measured in terms of the amount of space covered by CCTV, on the benefits of footage to criminal investigations.

Across the entire network, busier stations recorded a higher number of footage requests; however, once other variables were taken into account, an increase in patronage was actually associated with a decrease in the number of footage requests. Quieter stations may have fewer passengers around when incidents occur, particularly in the evening, providing fewer opportunities for other forms of surveillance (ie witnesses who may assist with an investigation). As with the number of cameras, this variable was not significant when the analysis was limited to metropolitan stations, either before or after the physical characteristics of stations were taken into account. It is possible that passenger numbers have a more significant influence on other forms of surveillance at quieter intercity stations.

In terms of station characteristics, stations that were accessible after hours and interchange stations (with two or more lines) recorded a higher number of footage requests for assault incidents, controlling for other variables. Stations that are accessible after hours, specifically, those with 24-hour staffing, will have periods of low footfall, as distinct from low footfall overall (already accounted for within the model). These stations may be more likely to record incidents at times when there are fewer passengers around and therefore fewer witnesses who can assist in a police investigation, such as late at night, including when the trains are not running. This suggests a need to target CCTV at locations which are accessible during periods of low patronage and which therefore lack other forms of public surveillance, but which may attract a higher number of incidents.

There may be several explanations for the high rate of requests at interchange stations, even once patronage is taken into account. Research into crime at train stations has found that the connectedness of a station, including whether it is an interchange, is associated with a higher rate of violent crime, because it provides opportunities for victims and offenders to come together in certain locations at specific times (Irvin-Erickson & La Vigne 2015). At interchanges, passengers spend longer periods waiting for connecting services, or moving between connecting services (eg trains, buses and ferries). It might be that these same properties lead to incidents in locations where other forms of public surveillance may not be present, such as pedestrian tunnels, or where other forms of public surveillance may be less effective, such as in particularly crowded areas or areas where large groups of passengers converge. It may be that CCTV cameras installed at interchanges provide surveillance of these locations, and that police request footage knowing there is coverage. Another explanation is that interchanges, often located in city centres and entertainment precincts, may have assault incidents that are qualitatively different to the assault incidents at other stations, the same could also be said for stations accessible after hours. These stations may have more alcohol-related assaults, which are more likely to involve serious injury and which may therefore involve closer inspection of available CCTV footage. Finally, given research has shown that police frequently use CCTV footage to verify witness accounts (La Vigne et al. 2011), police may request footage at interchanges because there are multiple, conflicting witness statements about an incident.

This research is not without its limitations. Incidents recorded by police at stations may have provided a better measure of the potential demand for CCTV footage, given police would be likely to seek footage only for incidents that come to their attention. However, police recorded crime data were not readily available with the same precision in terms of the location of incidents at train stations. In any case, the relationship and data-sharing arrangements between Sydney Trains and NSWPF mean that there is likely significant overlap between recorded criminal incidents and recorded security incidents.

Further, in-depth analysis of footage requests is limited to assaults, largely because of evidence that police are more likely to request footage of violent crime, but there may be some variability between offence types that has important implications for planning CCTV systems. In addition, there are many other variables that may influence a police officer’s decision to request CCTV footage of a security incident. For example, the placement of cameras and coverage at each station may have a much greater impact on this decision than the design of the station itself. Similarly, it was not possible to account for the characteristics of security incidents as part of the analysis, including when and where they occurred and how this might vary between stations, which might also influence requests for footage. Further, it was not possible to account for police officer preferences, US research has shown that police vary in their support for CCTV as an investigative tool (La Vigne et al. 2011).

Finally, further research into the use of CCTV footage by police is necessary, including research into the impact of footage on police investigations. While UK research by Ashby (2017) demonstrated the value of CCTV footage to British Transport Police, other research has shown that often the footage accessed by police does not assist with an investigation (La Vigne et al. 2011), and that outcomes can vary from country to country (Welsh & Farrington 2009). The rail network is also relatively unique in its level of CCTV coverage and monitoring arrangements, limiting the generalisability of results from this study to other locations. Therefore, future research should examine the use of CCTV in other settings, such as entertainment precincts, for investigative purposes.

Conclusion

While relatively modest in scope, this study represents one of the first attempts in Australia to measure the use of CCTV footage by police in criminal investigations. Overall, this study provides some empirical support for the argument that, to aid in investigations (especially for assault incidents), surveillance cameras should be installed at locations where there are higher levels of crime and lower levels of public surveillance, and at stations and locations that have crime-generating properties. Importantly, footage from cameras should be regarded as complementary to other forms of evidence that might be available from offenders, victims and witnesses. While further work is required to measure the impact of CCTV on investigation outcomes, this research demonstrates the frequency with which police use CCTV footage on a major rail network, and can help to inform the design and layout of CCTV systems both on public transport and in other locations.

Obtained from: Morgan A & Coughlan M 2018. Police use of CCTV on the rail network. Trends & issues in crime and criminal justice no. 561. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology. https://www.aic.gov.au/publications/tandi/tandi561

Need legal advice?

If you've been charged or contacted by police, get advice early. Mark Savic is available 24/7 for urgent matters in Airlie Beach, the Whitsundays and across Queensland.

Here for you 24/7

Guardian Criminal Law is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. If you're facing criminal charges, it's important to make contact as soon as possible.

Call 0418 956 910
Call 24/7: 0418 956 910