By Hayley Boxall and Anthony Morgan,
Abstract
The ability of first responder agencies to target resources at the highest risk domestic and family violence offenders and victims is limited by a lack of information about the timing of recidivism. This is particularly true for young people, who have typically been excluded from the risk literature.
This study analysed Victoria Police reported incident data on almost 4,000 young people (aged 12–18) involved in domestic and/or family violence. Approximately one in four young people were involved in repeat violence within six months, with the highest risk occurring at around three to four weeks. The likelihood of repeat incidents of violence increased significantly with every new event. A prior history of violence (including breaches) was associated with repeat violence in the short term.
The findings highlight the need for timely, targeted and graduated responses to domestic and family violence among young people.
Domestic and Family Violence
Introduction
Over the past 15 years, there has been a surge of interest in methods of identifying and responding to high-risk domestic violence (or intimate partner violence) and family violence offenders and victims, particularly among first responder agencies such as police. Correspondingly, many Australian state and territory police agencies now require officers responding to domestic and family violence (DFV) incidents to use risk assessment tools to estimate the likelihood of future offending (Dowling & Morgan 2019) and have implemented high-risk domestic violence (DV) offender teams which target repeat offenders (Fentiman 2017; NSW Government 2016). A number of short-term strategies have also been implemented to protect women at high risk of further abuse, particularly during the immediate period following an incident, and the lead-up to court proceedings. This includes GPS tracking of offenders (Bevin 2018) and the provision of panic alarms to victims (eg 3G Safety Watches and SafeTCards; ABC News 2012; Olding 2015).
One dimension of DFV risk which has received relatively little attention is the timing of repeat events. Considering the practical applications of this information, not to mention the growing evidence that risk of reoffending is highest in the first few months following a violent event, this is a notable gap in the risk literature (Klein & Crowe 2008; Morgan, Boxall & Brown 2018; Petersson & Strand 2017; Richards et al. 2014; Stansfield & Williams 2014). Certainly, the support needs of a victim who is at risk of repeat violence in the weeks following an incident are different from those of a survivor who may be revictimised in the next year, as are the treatment and response options for offenders.
Further, a small number of studies have found that the timing of DFV reoffending is related to both the escalation of harm (Kerr, Whyte & Strang 2017) and the frequency of reoffending (Barnham, Barnes & Sherman 2017; Bland & Ariel 2015; Kerr, Whyte & Strang 2017). For example, Morgan, Boxall and Brown’s (2018) analysis of short-term reoffending patterns within a sample of DV perpetrators in Tasmania found that the risk of reoffending was cumulative, increasing significantly with every subsequent reoffence occurring within a 60-day period. The same study also found that the time taken to the first reoffence was much shorter for offenders who reoffended multiple times during the six-month follow-up period (34 vs 59 days; Morgan, Boxall & Brown 2018). In interpreting these findings, the authors pointed to the possibility that preventing or delaying reoffending during the first few weeks and months following an incident could disrupt emerging (or established) longer-term patterns of violence. The findings from this study, and others like it, highlight the importance of preventing repeat offending in the short term, and of identifying offenders and victims who are at heightened risk after an incident.
An important limitation of the literature on DFV risk is its primary focus on adult offenders, adolescent family violence (AFV) has been excluded from mainstream DFV research for decades (Daff, McEwan & Luebbers 2018; Moulds et al. 2016; Routt & Anderson 2011; Simmons et al. 2018). There is a clear rationale for focusing on the risk profiles and violence patterns of young people involved in DFV. First, Australian statistics indicate that young people comprise a significant minority of the overall DFV offender population. Freeman (2018) reported that, of the 14,611 individuals proceeded against by the NSW Police Force in 2014 for DFV-related incidents, seven percent were under the age of 18. Similarly, Victoria Police statistics show that between April 2018 and March 2019, people aged 10–19 years comprised 10 percent of all individuals who were reported for incidents of family violence (Crime Statistics Agency 2019). Meanwhile, Australian research indicates that domestic violence is a common experience for young people. A recent survey of over 400 high school students in Melbourne (14–18 years old) found that 25 to 28 percent of respondents had experienced physical violence in their ‘most difficult relationship’, while 19 to 25 percent admitted to being physically violent (Daff, McEwan & Luebbers 2018). Estimates of victimisation and perpetration increased to three in four when emotional violence was examined (Daff, McEwan & Luebbers 2018).
Second, there is clear evidence that young people’s DFV behaviours are harmful and can have short- and long-term impacts on intimate partners and family members. For example, Freeman’s (2018) analysis of 200 police narratives for DFV incidents involving juveniles found that victims sustained a minor or serious injury in half of the incidents (54%), while a number of other studies have noted the impact of violence on the mental health and wellbeing of victims (Ackard, Eisenberg & Neumark-Sztainer 2007; Day & Bazemore 2011; Edenborough et al. 2008; Fitz-Gibbon, Elliott & Maher 2018; Glass et al. 2003).
Family violence (FV) has obvious implications for the relationships between the young person and their family members and the functioning of the family (Brezina 1999; Edenborough et al. 2008; Fitz-Gibbon, Elliott & Maher 2018). These harms may be compounded by societal beliefs that these behaviours are less serious than violence used by adults (Simmons et al. 2018), meaning victims may not seek support due to concerns about being dismissed or not believed by others, or even blamed (Miles & Condry 2016). Adolescent family violence is particularly likely to be subsumed under the banner of ‘problem behaviour’, with parents being held responsible for their children’s violence (Edenborough et al. 2008).
Finally, some research has indicated that juvenile DFV behaviours, particularly AFV, may be the ‘missing link’ in understanding the intergenerational transmission of intrafamilial violence, particularly the link between experiencing child abuse or witnessing DV between parents and perpetrating violence against intimate partners or other family members as an adult (Fitz-Gibbon, Elliott & Maher 2018; Foshee et al. 2005; Noland et al. 2004; Simmons et al. 2018; Ulman & Straus 2003; Vagi et al. 2013). Preventing the occurrence (and recurrence) of juvenile DFV behaviours may help break the cycle of intergenerational abuse. While this obviously requires an understanding of why some young people engage in these behaviours, and what treatment options and responses are appropriate when they occur, we also need to know when these responses should be deployed and who they should be targeted at in the short term.
Discussion
The violence histories of young people can be helpful for identifying who will be involved in repeat violence in the short term, and who will be involved in multiple violent incidents. Frequency of prior incidents of violence is a better predictor of future short-term reoffending than prevalence of prior violence, but they are both useful indicators of future risk. Simple, readily available indicators of elevated risk for short-term repeat incidents of violence are important, particularly given the challenges associated with using more complex risk assessment tools in the field (Dowling & Morgan 2019).
Taken together, the findings of this study provide a clear picture of the short-term repeat patterns of DFV among young people. Approximately one in four young people were involved in repeat violence in the six months following an incident, with the risk peaking at around 30 days following an incident for DV group members, and at around three to four weeks for FV group members. The timing of the second incident of violence is associated with subsequent patterns of violence. Specifically, young people who are reported for repeat violence sooner after the initial incident are more likely to reoffend on multiple occasions in the short term. Risk of repeat violence in the short term was also cumulative, increasing significantly with each violent incident. Although 39 percent of the young people who were involved in three violent incidents went on to reoffend a fourth time, they accounted for only two percent of the total sample.
Young people who had previously been apprehended by police for DFV and/or breach incidents were significantly more likely to be involved in repeat incidents of violence at 30, 60 and 180 days. However, the odds of repeat violence were much higher for young people who had been apprehended for at least two prior breaches and/or DFV incidents compared with those who had been reported only once or never before. Similarly, young people who had been reported for two or more prior violent incidents were more likely to be involved in multiple repeat incidents of violence during the six-month follow-up period. There is a small cohort of young people whose violent behaviours persist despite having contact with the police, and who go on to commit further violence against their partners or family members. Their repeated use of violence observed in this study could be the continuation of pre-existing patterns of abuse.
But for young people, as with adult offenders, the context in which these patterns of frequent, repeat incidents of DFV occur cannot be ignored. These periods of repeat violence may have coincided with a series of specific stressors that increased the likelihood of abuse. This could be a breakdown in their intimate and family relationships, a period of ill health, pregnancy, contact with the police, school performance problems or broader familial issues such as parental unemployment, separation or divorce (Contreras & Cano 2014; Edenborough et al. 2008; Glass et al. 2003; Noland et al. 2004; Vagi et al. 2013). When these issues are present, coupled with individual-level factors, the risk of repeat violence is elevated (Moulds et al. 2016; Simmons et al. 2018). This is particularly true when there are multiple potential targets of violence present, as is often the case with FV, as reflected in the high proportion of young people in the FV group whose violence was targeted at multiple victims.
Understanding of the situational factors that contribute to the occurrence and recurrence of AFV is currently very limited. A recent review of child-to-parent abuse literature conducted by Simmons and colleagues (2018: 39) identified a lack of research in this area, with the authors noting their surprise ‘given the evidence that aggression generally is contingent upon how factors interact with situational antecedents’. There is an obvious need to understand the situations in which young people engage in DFV, particularly in situations where repeat offending occurs within a short period of time. This information is essential for responding to high-risk young people, victims and families and for preventing further harm.
Although the purpose of this paper was not to compare the patterns of DFV among young people and adults, the findings from this study are remarkably consistent with those reported by Morgan, Boxall and Brown (2018) in their analysis of short-term reoffending patterns of a sample of adult DV perpetrators in Tasmania. The findings are also consistent with those of other studies examining the reoffending patterns of adult DV offenders (Klein & Crowe 2008; Richards et al. 2014; Stansfield & Williams 2014). The prevalence of repeat DFV among the young people in this study was nearly identical to that of adult DV offenders in Morgan, Boxall and Brown’s (2018) study at 14 days, 30 days, 60 days and 180 days, within a few percentage points at each interval. For example, at 60 days following the reference incident, the repeat violence rate was 14 percent for adult DV offenders and young DV offenders, and 16 percent for young FV offenders (Morgan, Boxall & Brown 2018). In both studies, those young people and adults who reoffended more quickly were more likely to be involved in repeat violence on multiple occasions. Both studies also observed an increase in the risk of repeat violence each time a person reoffended; by the third incident, the likelihood of a fourth incident occurring within 60 days was 39 percent for young people and 43 percent for adult offenders (Morgan, Boxall & Brown 2018). Both studies identified the frequency of prior violent incidents as an important predictor of future violence, although prior violence is obviously much less common among young people.
The repeat violence patterns of young people who engage in DFV and adult DV offenders are similar, and therefore the implications for the targeting, timing and graduation of responses are also similar. As with Morgan, Boxall and Brown (2018) and others (Stansfield & Williams 2014), this study emphasises the need for a more nuanced understanding of risk that considers the timing of repeat violent incidents, and recognises that the risk of repeat violence is not constant. It also highlights both the need for graduated responses to AFV, and the potential of these responses to prevent future harm to victims and break the cycle of abuse and violence that may be present within the relationships and families of young people who use violen
Need legal advice?
If you've been charged or contacted by police, get advice early. Mark Savic is available 24/7 for urgent matters in Airlie Beach, the Whitsundays and across Queensland.



