24/7 Hotline 0418 956 910 Free 30-minute consultation. Call to book Coral Sea Marina, Airlie Beach
Guardian Criminal Law

The impact of arrest and seizure on drug crime and harms: A systematic review

The impact of arrest and seizure on drug crime and harms: A systematic review

Elizabeth Eggins, Lorelei Hine, Angela Higginson and Lorraine Mazerolle

Introduction

About two-thirds of the Australian Government drug response budget goes to law enforcement (Ritter, Hughes & Hull 2016), and two of the key law enforcement mechanisms for controlling drug use are supplier arrest and seizures (Caulkins & Reuter 2010; Kilmer & Hoorens 2010). One of the underlying assumptions of law enforcement arrest and seizure responses to drug problems is that they will deter drug crime and drug
use, and thereby increase drug prices, impact purity and/or potency, and reduce drug harms more generally. Yet empirical evidence that examines the impact of supplier arrest and seizures on drug-related outcomes does not unequivocally support this basic deterrence assumption (see, for example, Mazerolle, Soole & Rombouts 2007; Reuter 2019, 1988; Wan et al. 2014). In fact, research suggests that reactive enforcement activities, such as seizures and arrests, can actually increase crime without reducing drug consumption or other harms (see, for example, Hughes et al. 2018; King & Mauer 2006). This systematic review of the impact of supplier seizure and arrest as law enforcement strategies for addressing drug crime, drug use, drug price, drug purity, and drug harms is therefore timely. It aims to provide comprehensive, clear, evidence-based guidance for Australian policy and practice.

Discussion

The results of this review demonstrate that there is limited high-quality scientific evidence that can be used to examine the impact of the law-enforcement mechanisms of supplier arrest and seizure on a range of drug-related outcomes. The locations of the eligible studies vary, and most of the studies examine increased drug law enforcement seizures rather than supplier arrest. In addition, study findings vary, with only three studies reporting sufficient data to calculate effect sizes. Given these variations in the included studies, it was not possible to quantitatively synthesise the reported data to consider the overall impact of supplier arrest or seizure on drug-related outcomes. These mixed findings and the inability to quantitatively synthesise the evaluation evidence have important implications. For instance, the existing evidence does not allow us to definitively conclude that arresting suppliers and seizing from suppliers will lead to desired outcomes such as reducing drug crime, drug use and other drug harms.

Our review provides brief qualitative summaries of the included studies, but we caution against a simple counting of the number of positive and negative findings studies to determine the overall effectiveness of supplier arrests or seizures. This counting approach is not recommended by either of the Campbell or Cochrane collaborations, the two global collectives who disseminate ‘gold standard’ systematic reviews of interventions, because it does not take into consideration methodological variations or other differences in the studies in the same way as meta-analysis. Instead, we recommend that the findings of each study are carefully considered in light of the data synthesised (eg geographical location) and the nature of local problems. We also note that the review is limited to research conducted between 2004 and 2018, which means that potentially eligible research conducted prior to 2004 is not included.

In sum, we make two key recommendations. First, we strongly recommend that future research rigorously examines the impact of drug supplier arrest and seizures, with a particular focus on collecting high-quality longitudinal data to permit sophisticated analysis that can answer nuanced questions with implications for policing practice (see eg Singleton et al. 2018); for example, the seizure and arrest thresholds that are required to disrupt drug markets and sustain those disruptions. Second, we recommend that policymakers, funding bodies and practitioners consider the use of proactive law enforcement initiatives that are place-focused and problem-focused, which have a stronger evidence base (eg see Mazerolle, Soule & Rombouts 2007; Mazerolle, Eggins & Higginson 2020).

Obtained from: Eggins E et al. 2020. The impact of arrest and seizure on drug crime and harms: A systematic review. Trends & issues in crime and criminal justice no. 602. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology. https://doi.org/10.52922/ti04688

Need legal advice?

If you've been charged or contacted by police, get advice early. Mark Savic is available 24/7 for urgent matters in Airlie Beach, the Whitsundays and across Queensland.

Here for you 24/7

Guardian Criminal Law is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. If you're facing criminal charges, it's important to make contact as soon as possible.

Call 0418 956 910
Call 24/7: 0418 956 910